The Court of Appeal upheld the decision in favor of the state and the Kyiv Pechersk Lavra National Reserve

The Court of Appeal upheld the decision in favor of the state and the Kyiv Pechersk Lavra National Reserve

On November 12, 2026, the Northern Commercial Court of Appeal dismissed the appeal of the UOC monastery in case No. 910/423/23 regarding the removal of obstacles to the use of the Assumption Cathedral and the Refectory Church with the Refectory Chamber on the territory of the Upper Lavra. The decision is final and has already entered into legal force.

The UOC monastery demanded through the court to restore access to these buildings for worship and religious ceremonies, insisting that the use agreements continued to be valid. The Kyiv City Commercial Court dismissed the claim on June 13, 2023, after which the monastery filed an appeal. The appellate court upheld the decision in favor of the Kyiv-Pechersk Lavra National Reserve.

“After more than three years of appeal, the court upheld the decision in favor of the Kyiv-Pechersk Lavra National Reserve. The Assumption Cathedral and the Refectory Church with the Refectory Chamber remain under the management of the Reserve. The state is responsible for the preservation of these monuments and access to them. Together with the Reserve, we are working to ensure that the monuments of the Upper Lavra are systematically restored and researched, and visitors have more opportunities to get acquainted with their history. I thank the Reserve team and all the lawyers who defended the interests of the state in court,” said Deputy Prime Minister of Ukraine for Humanitarian Policy of Ukraine – Minister of Culture of Ukraine Tetyana Berezhna.

The case was delayed due to numerous groundless motions systematically filed by representatives of the monastery and third parties. The court refused to satisfy them and repeatedly pointed out to the representatives of the monastery that they were abusing their procedural rights. Eventually, the court concluded the case and issued a decision.

“This is a very long-awaited decision that the National Reserve and Ukrainian society have been waiting for. Back in 2023, the court ruled in favor of the Reserve, but the unfinished appeal left the possibility of restoring and returning the influence of the “Russian world” here. I am grateful to everyone who joined the difficult legal work, to the Ministry of Culture of Ukraine and to Ukrainian society, which, with support in words and actions, helped us to persevere, maintain hope, and reach this final decision,” said Maksym Ostapenko, General Director of the National Reserve “Kyiv-Pechersk Lavra”.

Let us recall that the monastery used the Assumption Cathedral and the Refectory Church with the Refectory Chamber on the basis of two agreements for temporary free use dated June 17, 2016.

Their term of validity expired on December 31, 2022. The National Reserve notified in advance that the contracts had expired and that it would not renew them. In January 2023, the commission conducted an inventory and technical inspection of both buildings and formalized their return to the Reserve. The legal dispute over the use of these temples has been ongoing since 2023.

At the same time, another case regarding the Lower Lavra is being considered. It is also accompanied by numerous motions that are delaying the process. The proceedings have been suspended twice. After the National Reserve appealed, the Supreme Court overturned the ruling to suspend the proceedings and sent the case for further consideration.